Dice Logo ®
Dice Logo ®
  • Tech Careers
    • Job Search
    • Career Events
    • Dice Careers Mobile
  • Career Toolkit
  • Insights
  • Career Development Resources
  • For Employers
    • Search Resumes
    • Post Jobs
    • Talent Solutions
    • Resource Library
    • 2022 Salary Report
  • Login/Register
    • Login
    • Register
    • Employer Login
  • Tech Careers
  • Career Explorer
    • Career Toolkit Articles
  • Insights Home
  • Post Jobs
  • Talent Solutions
  • Login/Register
  • Your Career
    • Job Satisfaction
    • Career Growth
    • Soft Skills
  • Your Job Search
    • Salary
    • Job Interview Tips
    • Resume & Cover Letter Support
  • News
    • Technology Companies
    • Tech Events
    • Industry Reports
    • Tech Updates
  • Employer Resources
    • Recruiter Resources
      • Sourcing Talent
      • Salary Data
      • Interviewing Tips
      • Job Description Templates
      • Employer Brand
      • Virtual Hiring & Remote Work
      • Benefits
    • Staffing Resources
    • Hiring Trends
    • Employer Resource Library
  • 2022 Salary Report
  • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
  • Your Career
    • Job Satisfaction
    • Career Growth
    • Soft Skills
  • Your Job Search
    • Salary
    • Job Interview Tips
    • Resume & Cover Letter Support
  • News
    • Technology Companies
    • Tech Events
    • Industry Reports
    • Tech Updates
  • Employer Resources
    • Recruiter Resources
      • Sourcing Talent
      • Salary Data
      • Interviewing Tips
      • Job Description Templates
      • Employer Brand
      • Virtual Hiring & Remote Work
      • Benefits
    • Staffing Resources
    • Hiring Trends
    • Employer Resource Library
  • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion

Federal Judge Rules NSA Metadata Collection Legal

by Nick KolakowskiDecember 27, 20132 min read
AnalyticsmetadataNSAPrivacySecurity

A federal judge in New York has ruled that the National Security Agency (NSA) has the legal right to collect metadata on phone calls made within the United States.

In so doing, Judge William H. Pauley III of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed a legal challenge to the NSA’s surveillance activities by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). It also counters an earlier ruling, by Judge Richard Leon of the Federal District Court for the District of Columbia, that found the NSA’s metadata collection unconstitutional.

Pauley cited the need to effectively fight terrorism as his chief motivation behind the ruling. “Technology allowed al-Qaeda to operate decentralized and plot international attacks remotely,” he wrote in the lengthy ruling (PDF; hat tip to The Verge for posting it). “The bulk telephony metadata collection program represents the government’s counter-punch: connecting fragmented and fleeting communications to re-construct and eliminate al-Qaeda’s terror network.”

He added: “There is no evidence that the Government has used any of the bulk telephony metadata it collected for any purpose other than investigating and disruptive terrorist attacks.” At the same time, however, he also acknowledged NSA employees’ occasional violations of security and privacy guidelines, which he framed as “unintentional” and appearing to stem “from human error and the incredibly complex computer programs that support this vital tool.”

Despite the ruling, it’s likely this legal fight over NSA metadata will continue onwards, as the ACLU will almost certainly appeal—whether it reaches as far as the U.S. Supreme Court remains to be seen.

In June, government whistleblower Edward Snowden began feeding top-secret NSA documents (downloaded while he served as a system administrator at an agency outpost in Hawaii) to The Guardian and other newspapers. Many of those documents detailed the NSA’s metadata program, and ignited a firestorm of controversy. In response, President Barack Obama announced earlier this month that he plans on reining in the NSA’s surveillance programs, but won’t reveal exact steps until 2014.

 

Image: Brian A Jackson/Shutterstock.com

Related

  • Want to Store Secret NSA Metadata?
    Want to Store Secret NSA Metadata?
  • House Threatens Legal Basis of NSA Surveillance
    House Threatens Legal Basis of NSA Surveillance
  • NSA Logo
    All the NSA Cares About is How Well You Know Tech

Post navigation

Big Data Needs Big Wins in 2014
NSA Win Leaves Security of Cell, Cloud Data Uncertain

Click here to cancel reply.

YOUR CAREER. YOUR PATH.
Find out what you're worth.
Discover skills to earn more.
Apply for jobs.

All with the Dice Careers App.
Get It Now

Author Bio

Nick Kolakowski
Senior Editor
Nick Kolakowski has written for The Washington Post, Slashdot, eWeek, McSweeney's, Thrillist, WebMD, Trader Monthly, and other venues. He's also the author of "A Brutal Bunch of Heartbroken Saps" and "Maxine Unleashes Doomsday," a pair of noir thrillers.
Search Dice Insights
Dice Logo ®
Learn About Dice Insights
  • About Us
  • Contact Sales
  • Contact Us
  • Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • CCPA
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information
  • Work at Dice
Dice Services
  • Browse Jobs
  • Browse Companies
  • Social Recruiting
  • Support
Dice Everywhere
google-play-badge
Download_on_the_App_Store_Badge_US-UK_RGB_blk_092917
Copyright ©1990 - 2022 Dice . All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to certain Terms and Conditions.
dhi-neg-i Dice is a DHI service
Ad